Field marshal haig hero or butcher

Field marshal haig: “hero or butcher of the somme” i consider the field marshal as a butcher and a hero for numerous reasons while the insinuation of haig as a butcher ignores many positives that he possessed, the implication of him being a hero also neglects negatives that the field marshal obtains. Was haig the butcher of the somme essaysdoes haig deserve his nickname the butcher of the somme feild marshall haig was appointed commander of the army on 10th of december 1915, he was fifty-four at the time and he had had a very succesful military career haig decided to attack the germans. Field marshal douglas haig was known by his own side as the “butcher of the somme” and for good reason at loos in 1915, haig threw two entire divisions of inexperienced volunteers straight into battle as they arrived on the western front – with no rest, food, water and crucially little combat training. Butcher of the somme or hero of amiens tasks background historians agree that the major victories in the last ‘hundred days’ were mainly won by field marshall haig and the british army but haig’s final victory presents the historian with a problem send me the national archives’ newsletter a monthly round-up of news, blogs.

field marshal haig hero or butcher Field marshal sir douglas haig: war hero or butcher of the somme many historians see the somme as one of, if not the most, significant events of the war the devastating casualties and deaths of the war left thousands without their loved ones, a whole generation was lost at the somme.

Douglas haig, britain’s first world war commander-in-chief from december 1915 to the end of the war, is remembered as the archetypal ‘donkey’ leading ‘lions’ to their death by the thousands but, a century on, is this a fair judgement born in edinburgh, 19 june 1861, douglas haig was the. Field marshall douglas haig: butcher, bungler or hero the commander in chief when field-marshal earl haig died in 1928 it was estimated that at least one million people watched the funeral procession pass through the streets of london. General haig : hero, butcher or bungler the man pictured to the right is sir douglas haig he was the british document preview douglas by gary sheffield haig, douglas (field-marshal sir douglas haig, 1st earl haig of bemersyde) british soldier and commander-in-chief of the british. Douglas haig (1861-1928) was a top british military leader during world war i a graduate of the royal military college at sandhurst, haig fought in the sudan war and the south african war named.

Haig is one of the most controversial figures in world war one and the last century - haig fully deserves his reputation as 'bungler and butcher of the somme' introduction many think of his him as a national hero, where as others think of him a blundering fool who was not fit to lead an. We will write a custom essay sample on was the label “the butcher of the somme” a fair description of general haig specifically for you we will write a custom paper sample on was the label “the butcher of the somme” a fair description of general haig specifically for you for only field marshall haig: ‘the butcher of the somme. Haig’s wife believed that the ‘strain of wartime command had worn out his heart’, and the media began to print headlines, ‘field marshal a war victim’, haig was treated just like any soldier who had fought in the war, and he too was seen as a war casualty.

Field marshall haig sir douglas haig replaced sir john french as commander of the field marshal sir douglas haig: war hero or butcher of the free essay: field marshal sir douglas haig: war hero or butcher of the somme many historians see the somme as one of, if not the most, significant events of. To what extent is it fair to call general haig the butcher of the somme essay title: essay 'was general haig the butcher of the general haig a butcher not war hero essay - 123helpme general haig a butcher not war need essay sample on field marshall haig: ‘butcher of somme did general haig deserve to be the butcher of the somme did. Field marshall haig would have shot the leaders but dared not of course because they were aussies haig's nickname was the butcher he'd think nothing of sending thousands of men to certain death.

One of the greatest debates for almost a century now has involved the conduct of the british commander-in-chief during the great war, field marshal sir douglas haig many commentators have referred to haig as a 'butcher' who sent hundreds of thousands of men unnecessarily to their deaths. Field marshall douglas haig is most associated with the battle of the somme in world war one douglas haig was britain’s commander-in-chief during the somme battle and took much criticism for the sheer loss of life in this battle. - field marshal sir douglas haig: war hero or butcher of the somme many historians see the somme as one of, if not the most, significant events of the war the devastating casualties and deaths of the war left thousands without their loved ones, a whole generation was lost at the somme.

Field marshal haig hero or butcher

The actions of field marshall haig are considered by some evil, and others heroic many today refer to field marshall haig as butcher haig, for his costly tactics, yet others believe he was a great leader of the british army. Field marshall sir douglas haig was the commander-in-chief of the british expeditionary forces during world war i he is responsible for the now infamous battles of the somme and passchendaele (third battle of ypres) in which hundreds of thousands of men lost their lives in seemingly futile attempts to break the german front lines. Butcher, hero, or a bungler source: 'great battles of world war i'- anthony livesey (1989) haig was a quiet and shy man, but he was intelligent and ambitious and had great self-confidence. Field marshal douglas haig, 1st earl haig, kt, gcb, om, gcvo, kcie (/ h eɪ ɡ / 19 june 1861 – 29 january 1928) was a senior officer of the british army during the first world war he commanded the british expeditionary force (bef) on the western front from late 1915 until the end of the war.

  • Free essays on essay was douglas haig a hero or villain search how far was the field marshall douglas haig responsible for the failings of the british armies on the western front in 1916 and 1917 amon goeth: the masochistic nazi butcher.
  • Field marshal douglas haig's role in the world war i battle has made him a controversial military figure haig - buried at dryburgh abbey in the borders - was a hero at the end of the war but subsequently branded by some historians as a butcher.

Sir douglas haig, national heroor butcher field marshall french’s tactics had already been heavily criticised, but the disastrous losses at loos proved the final straw and was. On the 10th of december a new commander was appointed named field marshal sir douglas haig and aged 54 he had had a long military career as a celebrated cavalry officer douglas haig believed in the ‘big push. Was general haig the “butcher” or “hero” of the somme does haig deserve his nickname the butcher of the somme field marshall haig was appointed commander of the army on 10th of december 1915, he was fifty-four at the time and he had had a very successful military career. When field-marshal earl haig died in 1928 it was estimated that at least one million people watched the funeral procession pass through the streets of london.

field marshal haig hero or butcher Field marshal sir douglas haig: war hero or butcher of the somme many historians see the somme as one of, if not the most, significant events of the war the devastating casualties and deaths of the war left thousands without their loved ones, a whole generation was lost at the somme.
Field marshal haig hero or butcher
Rated 5/5 based on 43 review

2018.