Is an omnipotent god a coherent
Doesn't that mean he knows what we will do when he creates each and every one of us doesn't that mean we don't really have a choice he wires our brain when he makes us, and that determines the way we think and therefore what we choose to believe isn't that just taking away our free will and if god isn't omniscient and omnipotent (therefore never giving us a will of his own) then why trust him. All this is to say that since god has perfect knowledge, and since whatever he plans comes to pass exactly as planned, it doesn't seem coherent to me to speak of god as a potential infinitely omnipotent being. When monotheists describe their god, you will normally hear that this god is omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent and omnibenevolent one of my favourite youtubers, noelplum99, has made a number of videos recently focusing on omniscience. The omnipotence paradox is a family of paradoxes that arise with some understandings of the term 'omnipotent' the paradox arises, for example, if one assumes that an omnipotent being has no limits and is capable of realizing any outcome, even logically contradictory ideas such as creating square circles.
Traditional monotheism considers god as omnipotent the definition however is very controversial for our purposes i will define omnipotence at the very least, it must be a logically coherent claim, meaning it must not conflict with any other properties attributed to such a being if there is conflict, then the existence of such a. The idea of god (unit 1 topic 4) this topic covers three areas: the question of what we mean by 'god' and whether our concept of god is coherent ie whether it makes sense and is free from internal contradictions. Omnipotence paradox is a former featured articleplease see the links under article milestones below for its original nomination page (for older articles, check the nomination archive) and why it was removed: this article appeared on wikipedia's main page as today's featured article on january 9, 2006.
God cannot do anything that is not consistent with his nature, this can hardly equate to omnipotence since omnipotence should be infinite, not limited as a result of a nature god has power to do everything logically consistent with his nature. If god exists, then god is omnipotent, omniscient, and morally perfect if god is omnipotent, then god has the power to eliminate all evil if god is omniscient, then god knows when evil exists. Welcome to episode 42 (part ii of iv), where we'll be discussing the philosophical questions surrounding 'omniscience' for religious believers, considering the questions that surround the nature or attributes of god, is important in their attempt to form a coherent understanding of their creator. If god were omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent, then evil would not exist the concept of the god of classical theism is incoherent because within the attributes of god contradict each other and they also contradict our experience of the universe.
God is not omnipotent over logic, therefore god is made at the image of logic, but logic is a pure void with no contents if there is no existence before so existence is needed to shape that logic, that will then shape god who has no power over it. This post is part of my series on nicholas everitt's book the non-existence of godfor an index, see here i am currently working my way through chapter 13 of the book this chapter deals with the potential contradictions inherent in the concept of an omnipotent being. I am not arguing in this thread that god exists rather, i am arguing that the concept of god is coherent - that it is possible a person p is omnipotent at a time t if and only if he is able to bring about the existence of any logically contingent state of affairs x after t, the description of the. A coherent definition of a god by:kyle butt, ma original: god a a being conceived as the perfect, omnipotent, omniscient originator and ruler of the universe, the principal object of faith and worship in monotheistic religions” (2000, p 753) so coherent, in fact, is the definition of god that it is absent from books such as the. Divine omnipotence, therefore, if it is to be a coherent notion, must be something less than the complete omnipotence which is the possession of all logically possible powers it must be a narrower omnipotence, consisting in the possession of all logically possible powers which it is logically possible for a being with the attributes of god to.
Since the concept of god is underdetermined by the biblical data and since what constitutes a great-making property is to some degree debatable, philosophers working within the judaeo-christian tradition enjoy considerable latitude in formulating a philosophically coherent and biblically faithful doctrine of god. Third, in light of the previous two conclusions, it seems plausible to claim that we should draw a careful line between the (secular) idea of omnipotence, and the (religious) idea of divine power. Since a rock that an omnipotent being could not lift is a logical impossibility, and has no coherent definition itself, the inability to create such a thing is not a limit on omnipotence, much as not being able to create a square circle isn't a limit the coherence of god - omnipotence #59 by wonkey » mar 15, 2010 8:34 pm and flying. God can commit evil (omnipotence), but always chooses not to (goodness) in talking of ‘a stone that an omnipotent being cannot lift’, it assumes that the concept of an omnipotent being is coherent but that is just what is at issue savage’s argument.
Is an omnipotent god a coherent
-if god is omnipotent, it means he has the power to do anything so, hypothetically, does god have the power to do something even he didn't know he was going to do -if he cannot, it means he is not omnipotent because he does not have the power to do so. My problem with omniscience and omnipotence begins with the christian view of god, a god that is loving and good, yet allows evil, knowing it will occur that's an old argument however not to say it isn't valid, it's just that there are already tons of discussions about it. Does god exist: the omnipotence paradox the point of the paradox is to show that the concept of omnipotence is impossible, and thus an omnipotent god – like the judeo-christian god – is a logically impossible being and must not exist “ can god create a rock that even he cannot lift” seems like a coherent question because the. The traditional omniscient, omnipotent god knows all things, including what things will happen in the future that knowledge includes his own future actions, which prevents him from choosing other actions, creating a contradiction.
Being omnipotent or omniscient is part of god’s nature”—page 242  logical necessity, a posterior necessity, necessity of the past, causal ultimacy, everlasting existence, and physical necessity. The idea of god being omnipotent is a central, or vital, part of the core beliefs of the main monotheistic religions of the world today: christianity, islam and judaism. Making a stone that cannot be lifted by an omnipotent being is only a contradiction if omnipotence is a coherent concept the purpose of the paradox is to determine whether or not the concept is coherent.
4 the attributes of god omnipotence the claim that god is omnipotent is the claim that god has unlimited power to perform basic actions while having established that god is coherent in abstracto let us now consider whether it is coherent to suppose god exists in view of the fact of human suffering. Omnipotence omnipotence is the property of being all-powerful it is one of the traditional divine attributes in western conceptions of godthis notion of an all-powerful being is often claimed to be incoherent because a being who has the power to do anything would, for instance, have the power to draw a round square. “is the concept of god coherent and intelligible” if i am to seek a true answer here, i must first ask whether or not the concept of god is coherent and intelligible in accordance to what we, as a populous, know to be real and true – and then, in accordance to that which we as a populous define as being sensible, and possible.